Ohio State’s quarterback battle has been one of the hottest topics in college football, with fans and analysts alike debating whether five-star recruit Julian Sayin or in-state standout Tavien St. Clair will lead the Buckeyes in the 2025 season. The competition has been fierce, but according to a trusted Ohio State insider, a clear frontrunner has emerged.
Multiple sources close to the program confirm that head coach Ryan Day and offensive coordinator Chip Kelly have begun to lean in one direction, with an official announcement expected before the Buckeyes’ annual spring game. While both quarterbacks have displayed elite talent, decision-making, and leadership throughout winter workouts, one has reportedly separated himself from the other.
So, who has the edge?
The Tale of Two Quarterbacks
The Ohio State quarterback battle has captured national attention due to the immense talent of both competitors.
Julian Sayin: The Highly Touted Transfer
Julian Sayin arrived in Columbus with sky-high expectations. A former five-star prospect and Alabama signee, Sayin transferred to Ohio State after Nick Saban’s retirement and a shake-up in the Crimson Tide’s coaching staff. Considered one of the most polished passers in recent recruiting history, Sayin possesses elite accuracy, poise in the pocket, and a high football IQ.
At 6’2”, 205 pounds, Sayin has the frame and mechanics that NFL scouts covet. He impressed immediately during Ohio State’s winter workouts, showcasing his quick release and ability to read defenses. Sayin’s supporters argue that he brings the experience and pedigree needed to lead the Buckeyes back to the College Football Playoff.
Tavien St. Clair: The Hometown Hero
On the other side of the battle is Tavien St. Clair, the homegrown phenom from Bellefontaine, Ohio. Unlike Sayin, St. Clair has been committed to Ohio State since early in his high school career, developing deep ties with the program and its coaching staff.
At 6’4”, 215 pounds, St. Clair brings a prototypical quarterback build, a strong arm, and deceptive athleticism. His deep-ball accuracy and ability to extend plays make him a dynamic threat, and his leadership qualities have endeared him to teammates. Many believe that, despite Sayin’s five-star reputation, St. Clair’s familiarity with Ohio State’s system gives him an advantage.
The Insider’s Verdict: Who Has the Edge?
According to an Ohio State insider who has observed practices firsthand, Julian Sayin has taken a commanding lead in the battle and is expected to be named the starter for the Buckeyes heading into summer workouts.
“Julian has been sharper in every aspect—his decision-making, his command of the offense, and his ability to handle pressure situations. The staff loves his poise and accuracy, and he’s really separated himself over the last few weeks,” the insider revealed.
Sayin has reportedly impressed coaches with his ability to quickly grasp Ohio State’s offensive system, which has undergone changes under Chip Kelly. The former Oregon and UCLA head coach was brought in to reinvigorate the Buckeyes’ attack, and Sayin’s skill set appears to align perfectly with Kelly’s up-tempo, quarterback-friendly scheme.
“Chip Kelly’s offense is all about efficiency, precision, and quick reads,” another source said. “Julian is the perfect fit. He processes information incredibly fast, and he doesn’t make many mistakes. That’s what Ryan Day and Chip Kelly are looking for.”
What This Means for Tavien St. Clair
While Sayin may be the projected starter, St. Clair isn’t out of the picture. The Ohio native has continued to impress with his raw talent and leadership, and sources say the coaching staff remains extremely high on his potential.
“Tavien isn’t far behind,” the insider noted. “He’s got all the tools, and if anything happens, he’ll be ready to step in.”
Some within the program believe that St. Clair could still close the gap during summer workouts, particularly if Sayin struggles with consistency in live-game situations. Additionally, given the unpredictable nature of college football, having two elite quarterbacks on the roster provides Ohio State with rare depth at the position.
Reactions from the Buckeyes Community
The revelation that Sayin is the frontrunner has sparked a heated debate among Ohio State fans. Some view him as the natural choice, pointing to his elite accuracy and decision-making as reasons he should start. Others believe St. Clair deserves the job based on his commitment to the program and long-term potential.
Former Ohio State quarterback and current Big Ten analyst Kirk Herbstreit weighed in on the debate, saying:
“This is a great problem for Ohio State to have. Sayin is a future NFL quarterback, no question. But Tavien St. Clair is the type of guy who bleeds scarlet and gray. If you’re Ryan Day, you have to make a decision that not only helps you win now but also sets you up for the future.”
The Bigger Picture: Ohio State’s 2025 Championship Hopes
Regardless of who starts at quarterback, the Buckeyes are positioned as a national title contender. With elite weapons at wide receiver, a revamped offensive line, and a defense that showed significant improvement last season, Ohio State is widely considered a top-three team heading into 2025.
The quarterback decision will be crucial, as the Buckeyes face early-season tests against Notre Dame and Penn State. If Sayin is indeed named the starter, his ability to perform under pressure will be closely scrutinized.
Meanwhile, St. Clair must decide whether to stay and compete for the job or explore other opportunities. With the transfer portal now a major factor in college football, quarterbacks who don’t win starting jobs often look elsewhere for playing time. However, sources close to St. Clair say he remains committed to the Buckeyes and is willing to wait for his opportunity.
Final Thoughts: An Official Announcement Looms
With the Ohio State spring game approaching, all eyes will be on the quarterbacks. While Julian Sayin appears to be the frontrunner, Ryan Day has yet to make an official announcement, leaving the door slightly open for a surprise.
Still, if the insider reports are accurate, Buckeye Nation should prepare to see Sayin under center when Ohio State takes the field for its 2025 season opener. His precision, poise, and fit within Chip Kelly’s system make him the logical choice to lead the Buckeyes in their quest for a national championship.
But in Columbus, nothing is ever set in stone. If history has taught us anything, it’s that the quarterback battle at Ohio State is never truly over until the first snap of the season.
