In a move that has left many Collingwood supporters reeling, rising star Archie May, the step-son of an AFL legend, has been snatched away by a rival Victorian club, sending shockwaves through the footy world.
The 18-year-old, who has drawn attention for his athleticism, sharp footy IQ, and family connection to one of the game’s greats, had long been expected to don the black and white. Instead, his sudden signing with a long-time rival has sparked frustration, disappointment — and plenty of “salty” reactions online.
A Family Legacy Interrupted
Archie May isn’t just any up-and-comer. As the step-son of a revered Collingwood figure — whose legacy still looms large at the club — fans felt certain that May would follow in his stepfather’s footsteps. Many believed it was only a matter of time before he was officially welcomed into the Magpie nest.
But in a shock twist, a rival Victorian club swooped in and sealed the deal with May, reportedly offering not only a stronger development pathway but also a personal pitch that convinced him to forge his own name, rather than ride on family ties.
Collingwood Fans React: ‘Gutted’ and ‘Blindsided’
The backlash from Collingwood supporters was immediate. Social media platforms lit up with commentary ranging from disbelief to outright anger. Words like “gutted”, “betrayed”, and “how did we let this happen?” dominated fan forums, while others turned their frustration toward club management for not securing May earlier.
One fan wrote, “I can’t believe he’s going — his name was practically penciled in for our future midfield. Another miss for the Pies.”
Another added, “Feels like déjà vu. We’ve lost too many talents to our rivals. This one stings more because of who he’s connected to.”
The Other Side of the Story
From May’s perspective, sources close to the young star say the move was about carving out his own path. While he respects his stepfather’s legacy, Archie is determined to create his own identity — away from the shadows and pressures of the Collingwood faithful.
The club that signed him has reportedly laid out a clear and aggressive development plan, emphasizing their intent to make May a centerpiece of their rebuild. The message was clear: here, you’re not just the step-son of a legend — you’re the future.
What’s Next for Collingwood?
This isn’t the first time the Magpies have missed out on a promising name, but this one may hurt more because of the emotional ties. With fans calling for accountability and some questioning the club’s recruitment strategy, there may be internal reviews to come.
Still, insiders say Collingwood remains confident in its next generation of talent, even if May won’t be part of it.
Final Thoughts
In the high-stakes world of AFL recruiting, emotions often run high — and stories like Archie May’s show just how deeply the game cuts into the hearts of fans. As the dust settles, May will be watched closely by both his new club’s faithful and the Magpie army, who will no doubt wonder what could have been.
One thing is certain: the next time May steps onto the field against Collingwood, the atmosphere will be electric — and possibly just a bit bitter.
