Nathan Cleary has reportedly spoken with deep emotion about Dylan Edwards’ decision to leave the Penrith Panthers, admitting it is painful to see one of the club’s most loyal and hardworking players move on. The Panthers halfback described Edwards as more than just a teammate, calling him a brother who helped shape the culture and success of the club over many years.
Cleary said losing Edwards would leave a major gap both on and off the field. While fans know Edwards for his fearless kick returns, elite fitness, and consistency at fullback, Cleary explained that his greatest value came through leadership, humility, and the standards he set every day at training.
“He’s the kind of player every team wants,” Cleary said. “He never complains, always works hard, and always puts the team first. It hurts to see a brother leave.”
There are believed to be several key reasons behind Edwards’ decision to depart Penrith.
1. Salary Cap Pressure
The Panthers have built one of the strongest squads in the NRL, but keeping star players together is never easy under the salary cap. With big contracts already tied to elite names across the roster, Edwards may have received a significantly better financial offer elsewhere. After years of service, he may feel it is the right time to secure his long-term future.
2. Desire for a New Challenge
After winning multiple premierships and achieving enormous success at Penrith, Edwards may simply want a fresh start. Many players eventually seek a new environment to test themselves, take on leadership responsibilities, or prove they can succeed outside a dominant system.
3. Family and Lifestyle Considerations
Personal life often plays a major role in career decisions. Whether it involves relocating closer to family, lifestyle preferences, or planning for life after football, players regularly weigh these factors when considering their future.
4. Career Recognition
Despite being one of the most reliable fullbacks in the competition, Edwards has sometimes been underrated compared with flashier stars. A move to another club could give him the chance to become the face of a team and receive the recognition his performances deserve.
Cleary acknowledged that while the decision is difficult for teammates and fans, he understands why Edwards may need to move forward.
“You always want what’s best for your mates,” Cleary said. “Even if it’s hard for us, you support them.”
If Edwards does depart, Penrith will lose more than a fullback—they will lose a symbol of resilience, loyalty, and relentless effort. For Cleary, the sadness is simple: saying goodbye to someone who helped build a dynasty beside him.
